The charming coastal city of Cape May has been a hotspot for beachside vacations since 1766. The historic beach haven draws in new and returning guests year after year looking to enjoy sandy shores and the area’s rich culture and heritage. Cape May is also home to a growing foodie scene that ranges from seafood to tacos and quick bites to fine dining experiences. Taste your way through our seaside town with these five foods you must try in Cape May!
Waffle Nutella from George’s Place
What better way to start the day than with a fluffy waffle topped with rich, warm Nutella, ripe bananas, and a generous sprinkling of powdered sugar and walnuts to finish it off? George’s Place is a Cape May institution that not only does breakfast right but offers unique dishes with a Mediterranean flair all day long.
Lobster Rolls from Quincy’s Original Lobster Rolls
Try a classic lobster roll from this harbor side favorite. Tender Maine Lobster chunks with lemon butter and light seasoning on a warm buttery roll make for the perfect midday meal. Want something different? Quincy’s offers a variety of lobster-centered dishes to satiate any craving.
The Signature “Tornado” Dog from Hot Dog Tommy’s
A staple in the Cape May community, HotDog Tommy’s serves up quality dogs with unique topping choices. Their signature hot dog combination, dubbed “The Tornado” dog, comes topped with mashed potatoes, chili, shredded cheddar cheese, salsa, banana peppers, and sour cream! Customize your dog to fit your taste buds, and with options ranging from classic to vegetarian, there’s something for everyone.
Tomahawk Porkchop from Washington Inn
Enjoy an impressive fine dining experience at Cape May’s Washington Inn. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a vacation night out, The Tomahawk Porkchop is a crowd favorite. Accompanied by a creamy celery root mash, bacon lardon braised collard greens, and flavorful mustard sauce, this tender cut will have you looking forward to a return trip to Cape May.
Peanut Butter Cannolis from Cape May Peanut Butter Company
A delicious crunchy cannoli shell is filled with creamy whipped peanut butter flavored filling to create a unique dessert experience. Stop by Cape May Peanut Butter Co. and explore the peanut butter lovers haven with products from butterscotch peanut butter, to peanut printed socks, to peanut butter ice cream. You’ll leave trying to figure out how you’re going to fit all your goodies in your suitcase to go back home!
Stay at Stockton Inns
Located just minutes from our picks for foods you must try in Cape May, we offer beachfront accommodations at our Victorian mansion, the Stockton Manor, and our budget-friendly hotel at the Stockton Inn. Stay near Washington Street Mall, and the best of Cape May, plus our location along Beach Avenue provides direct access to the beaches.
The Stockton Manor is Cape May’s only oceanfront Victorian Inn with a pool, plus it offers plenty of charm and character for a truly unique experience. Or, if you are looking for a more budget-friendly option for the entire family, book a room at our oceanfront motel. The Stockton Inn offers an ocean-view sundeck, outdoor lounge chairs, and rooms with your basic modern amenities.
