If you’re planning a getaway to the Jersey Shore, diving into the local seafood scene is a must—and lobster in Cape May is as good as it gets. From buttery rolls to seafood pot pies and elegant surf & turf, these local restaurants serve up some of the best lobster dishes around. Here’s your guide to the top places to enjoy lobster in Cape May during your next coastal escape.
La La Lobster
732 Beach Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204
La La Lobster delivers East Coast classics with serious flavor. Their creamy lobster bisque, rich lobster mac and cheese, and iconic lobster rolls are local favorites. Owner Nicole brings two decades of culinary experience to the table, sourcing high-quality ingredients from local farms and purveyors. This place is all about freshness and flavor, served with a personal touch.
The Lobster House
Fisherman’s Wharf, Cape May, NJ 08204
An institution in Cape May, The Lobster House offers a dockside dining experience like no other. Enjoy your meal aboard their historic sailing vessel, surrounded by waterfront views. They’re known for an impressive variety of lobster dishes—from lobster salad to whole stuffed lobster and live lobster from the tank. It doesn’t get fresher than this.
Cape May Fish Market
408 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204
Located in the heart of the Washington Street Mall, this spot is perfect for a casual yet flavorful lobster experience. Whether you’re into steamed lobster, lobster rolls, or their unique raw bar lobster cocktail, Cape May Fish Market has something to satisfy every seafood craving. Bonus: It’s BYOB, so bring your favorite bottle!
Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar
615 Lafayette Street, Cape May, NJ 08204
For a more elevated yet welcoming setting, Oyster Bay pairs polished service with outstanding seafood. Don’t miss their lobster pot pie or the filet and lobster tail surf & turf. With expert chefs and a cozy interior, it’s a great pick for a romantic dinner or special night out.
Quincy’s Original Lobster Rolls
320 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Quincy’s brings New England flair to Cape May with authentic, buttery lobster rolls inspired by Maine’s coastal cuisine. It’s a go-to for quick, casual eats while shopping or sightseeing downtown—generous lobster portions on toasted buns never disappoint.
Fins Bar & Grille
142 Decatur St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Fun, fresh, and full of flavor, Fins is a vibrant spot to enjoy lobster and live music in one place. The menu includes whole steamed lobster and other creative takes, paired with great cocktails and a lively vibe. Ideal for dinner after a day at the beach.
Stay at the Stockton Inns
Located along Beach Avenue, we offer beachfront accommodations at our Victorian mansion, the Stockton Manor, and our budget-friendly hotel at the Stockton Inn.
The Stockton Manor is Cape May’s only oceanfront Victorian Inn with a pool, plus it offers plenty of charm and character for a truly unique experience. Or, if you are looking for a more budget-friendly option for the entire family, book a room at our oceanfront motel. The Stockton Inn offers an ocean-view sundeck, outdoor lounge chairs, and rooms with your basic modern amenities.
Cass Tooke is a writer who focuses on travel, outdoor fun, and local culture. When not working, she enjoys watching movies, listening to her record collection, and biking with her boyfriend, Ryan. She also dreams of earning that Paul Hollywood handshake and making it on the Great British Baking Show one day.