As the day winds down and the ocean breeze cools the air, Cape May starts to sparkle in a different way — on stage. If you love the thrill of live performances, from Broadway-level productions to timeless American tales, the Cape May theater scene is your kind of night out.
Cape May Stage
Tucked inside a charming 1853 church, Cape May Stage brings big talent to a cozy, intimate space. You’ll find everything from sharp comedies to moving dramas, all performed by seasoned pros who know how to captivate a room. Every seat is close to the action — it’s theater that feels personal.
East Lynne Theater Company
Love stories that transport you? East Lynne Theater Company takes you back with classics full of heart, mystery, and historical depth. Their shows channel the soul of old American theater, making every performance feel like a step into another time.
Dinner and a Show?
Before the curtain rises, treat yourself to a local favorite:
- The Washington Inn — Elegant and intimate, perfect for date night.
- Tisha’s — Fresh, flavorful, and just steps from the action.
- The Ebbitt Room — A polished, farm-to-table gem that never disappoints.
Keep the Night Going
The final bow doesn’t have to mean the end of your evening. After the show, Cape May invites you to linger a little longer — grab a drink, share your favorite moments from the play, and enjoy the town’s cozy nighttime charm.
- The Brown Room – Chic, intimate, and perfect for sipping handcrafted cocktails in style.
- The Mad Batter – Fun and full of character, with creative drinks and a relaxed buzz.
- The Rusty Nail – Kick back at this beachfront favorite where flip-flops are welcome and the vibe is always easygoing.
Stay at the Stockton Inns
Located along Beach Avenue, we offer beachfront accommodations at our Victorian mansion, the Stockton Manor, and our budget-friendly hotel at the Stockton Inn.
The Stockton Manor is Cape May’s only oceanfront Victorian Inn with a pool, plus it offers plenty of charm and character for a truly unique experience. Or, if you are looking for a more budget-friendly option for the entire family, book a room at our oceanfront motel. The Stockton Inn offers an ocean-view sundeck, outdoor lounge chairs, and rooms with your basic modern amenities.
Cass Tooke is a writer who focuses on travel, outdoor fun, and local culture. When not working, she enjoys watching movies, listening to her record collection, and biking with her boyfriend, Ryan. She also dreams of earning that Paul Hollywood handshake and making it on the Great British Baking Show one day.