Welcome to Cape May, the picturesque city on the southern tip of New Jersey known for its stunning beaches, Victorian architecture, and delicious food. While Cape May is a popular destination for vacationers, there are some hidden gems in this city that only locals and insiders know about – the secret bars and restaurants in Cape May that are off the beaten path.
Iccara Italian Bistro & Seafood
This family-owned establishment offers a unique blend of classic Italian dishes and fresh seafood creations, all made with high-quality ingredients and served in a warm and inviting atmosphere. The menu features a range of options, from traditional pasta dishes like fettuccine alfredo and lasagna to seafood favorites such as crab cakes and pan-seared scallops.
Mayer’s Tavern
Mayer’s Tavern has been a fixture of the community for over 70 years. The restaurant boasts a warm and inviting atmosphere, complete with exposed brick walls and rustic wooden beams. The menu at Mayer’s Tavern features a variety of classic American fare, including fresh seafood, steaks, and burgers, as well as a selection of craft beers and signature cocktails.
Mermaids Restaurant
Situated just a few steps away from the beach, this restaurant offers stunning ocean views to its diners. Their menu features a variety of Mediterranean and seafood dishes, including kebabs and linguini with clams. Mermaids also serves delicious breakfast to help fuel you up before your day in Cape May!
Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar
Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar offers a casual and relaxed atmosphere with a nautical-themed decor, perfect for enjoying the fresh catch of the day. Oyster Bay’s menu features a wide variety of seafood dishes, including raw bar items, salads, sandwiches, and entrees such as lobster tail, jumbo shrimp, and seared scallops. In addition to their delicious seafood options, Oyster Bay also offers a variety of cocktails, beers, and wines to accompany your meal. With its picturesque location, flavorful cuisine, and friendly staff, Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar is a must-visit destination for seafood lovers in Cape May.
In conclusion, Cape May may be a popular vacation destination, but there are still some hidden gems waiting to be discovered. Whether you’re in the mood for fine dining, craft cocktails, fresh seafood, or sweet treats, there are secret bars and restaurants in Cape May waiting for you. So why not step off the beaten path and discover these hidden gems for yourself? You won’t be disappointed.
Stay at the Stockton Inns
2023 marks our 50th anniversary of hosting Cape May getaways! We’re excited to announce our raffle, where every room gets one ticket upon check-in for a chance to win two free nights during the 2024 season. We’ll be drawing one lucky winner every month from April through October, and any remaining tickets will stay in the running until the end of the season. Don’t miss your chance to win big!
The Stockton Manor & Inn is Cape May’s only oceanfront Victorian Inn with a pool, plus it offers plenty of charm and character for a truly unique experience. Or, if you are looking for a more budget-friendly option for the entire family, book a room at our oceanfront motel. The Stockton Inn offers an ocean-view sundeck, outdoor lounge chairs, and rooms with your basic modern amenities. You can now book your 2023 trip to Stockton Inns! We are open from April 28th to October 9th!
Cass Tooke is a writer who focuses on travel, outdoor fun, and local culture. When not working, she enjoys watching movies, listening to her record collection, and biking with her boyfriend, Ryan. She also dreams of earning that Paul Hollywood handshake and making it on the Great British Baking Show one day.